Three US Jefferson nickels from 1943 and 1944 displayed in a grid.
via Canva

An estate sale can by its very design go on to fetch exceedingly hungry buyers. In general, an estate sale is attended by people that due to whatever factoring circumstances can afford to drop their big purses on vintage items. These vintage estate sale items are the ones to keep an eye out for.

1. Vintage Jewelry

Liudmila Chernetska/istockphoto

It’s something of a “golden” rule to ensure that you suss out the imposters in the realm of jewelry and keep an eye out for hallmarks or stamps that indicate real gold, silver, and platinum. And make sure that you don’t overlook any of the smaller items, such as brooches or cufflinks, because they can end up being created with precious metals or gemstones and then resold for a profit.

2. Midcentury Modern Furniture

A wooden dresser with six drawers, each featuring a metal handle, stands on a grassy lawn in front of a light-colored siding wall and green plants.
diane555/istockphoto

Midcentury modern is still incredibly popular, and if you stumble across a statement piece from designers like Eames or Herman Miller, you should snap them up. Whether it’s a table or a chair, these pieces can be incredibly valuable and have serious staying power. Be sure to thoroughly inspect any piece of furniture before you purchase it though, as repairs on midcentury items can be costly.

3. Vintage Tools

simonkr/istockphoto

Vintage tools, antique hand tools are valued for both their durability and their craftsmanship. There are brands like Stanley, Anchor, and Disston that are exceedingly valuable and also appeal to collectors and woodworkers who prefer these quality tools over modern alternatives. To identify the most valuable ones, the key is to look for tools with minimal rust, intact handles, and original branding.

4. Beanie Babies

#1 bear beanie baby
HobbyUpNorth/ebay

The Beanie Baby craze of the ’90s left behind a treasure trove of collectibles. Value hinges on rarity, condition, and whether the original Ty tag is still attached. Consider also looking for rare editions, like Princess the Bear, or errors in manufacturing, as these can fetch hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Those stored in their original glass cases will be worth the most.

5. Family Heirlooms

brebca/istockphoto

Family heirlooms, such as handmade quilts, engraved silverware, or antique furniture- not only offer a glimpse into the past but can also be resold for surprising amounts. They’re particularly valuable if they carry unique details like hand-stitching or monograms, or were made from rare materials. Even if they’re not in perfect condition, their story and authenticity can make them highly valuable.

6. Pop Culture Memorabilia

Simpsons Vintage T-shirt
iro11i11/eBay

Everything from vintage band t-shirts to rare movie posters can have value, as long as you know what to look for. If you stumble across an item of pop culture memorabilia at an estate sale, do a quick Google search to determine its significance. Was it from a famed, once-in-a-lifetime concert? Is the item signed? Bonus points if it was actually worn or used by an artist.

7. Antiques

An assortment of vintage silverware, including teapots, cups, and trays, displayed on a table. The pieces have an ornate, ribbed design. The table has additional small items, hinting at a market or antique fair setting.
Punkbarby/iStock

Antique furniture, clocks, and home decor from the 18th or 19th century are hot commodities for both vintage collectors and mid-century decor enthusiasts. Items like Victorian-era mirrors, Art Deco dressers, or mid-century modern chairs can be resold for a pretty penny. Look for pieces with original finishes, intricate carvings, and minimal restoration. And when in doubt, don’t be afraid to ask questions about an item’s origin; provenance can help boost an item’s worth.

8. Vinyl Records

A stack of vintage vinyl records sits on a table next to old books and magazines. A colorful magazine with images of people is partially visible in the foreground. The setting has a nostalgic, retro vibe.
fikretozk/istockphoto

Vinyl records have made an impressive comeback in recent years as more people are drawn to the rich and warmer sound quality of analog music. Compared to digital alternatives like Spotify, first editions or rare pressings of vinyl albums by acclaimed artists like The Beatles, Pink Floyd, or Led Zeppelin have soared in value today. A nifty trick is to look for albums that feature unique cover art or have a “limited edition” label on them.

9. Artwork

Diego Rivera painting
Screenshot via PBS

Original paintings, prints, or sculptures by well-known artists can be another lucrative find. Look up the artist first to determine if their work is worth anything, and keep an eye out for things like certificates or gallery labels to verify authenticity. Even unsigned pieces can be rare gems if they’re well-executed or come from a specific era. Lastly, don’t overlook smaller artwork as these can be equally as valuable (if not more) than larger pieces.

10. Vintage Clothing

A closet with various dresses hanging on a rack, surrounded by high heels and boots on the floor. A large bag sits on a white stand, and a tall mirror leans against the wall. Decor includes dried grass in a vase.
triocean/istockphoto

Designer vintage clothing from brands like Chanel, Dior, or Yves Saint Laurent reflects changing fashion trends and can be a gold mine among collectors and fashionistas. Look for unique patterns, high-quality fabrics, and intact stitching to identify the most valuable items, and keep in mind that accessories like handbags, scarves, or hats (especially if they are tied to famous people) can also be highly lucrative when resold.

11. Books

A tall stack of various books and magazines piled unevenly on a flat surface. The collection includes hardcover and paperback books with colorful covers, along with some papers, all against a plain white background.
MeryVu/istockphoto

First editions or signed copies of classic literature aren’t just exceptionally rare, they can be resold for thousands of dollars, as evidenced by this signed copy of “A Farewell to Arms” that’s listed for over $7,000. Keep an eye out for books by acclaimed authors like Hemingway, Fitzgerald, or Tolkien, and check for rarity, condition, and any inscriptions or signatures.

Dust jackets, if present and intact, can significantly boost a book’s value, and even lesser-known titles can be worth a lot if they were part of a limited print run.

12. Coins and Currency

IURII BUKHTA/istockphoto

Rare or historical coins and bills can be worth far more than their face value. Look for mint marks, dates, and condition to determine their worth, and keep an eye out for coins from specific eras (think Roman or Civil War-era currency). Paper money with unique serial numbers or errors can also fetch high prices.

13. Cameras and Lenses

JackF/istockphoto

Old school cameras from brands like Leica, Nikon, or Rolleiflex are hot commodities for both photography enthusiasts and collectors of vintage tech. As a general rule of thumb, the more original and complete the camera is, the higher its value will be. Look for models that come with their original lenses, cases, and even instruction manuals, as these accessories can boost their worth. Cameras in working condition will be most valuable, but even non-functioning models can resell for high hundreds.

Remember to also pay attention to the condition and look for any scratches, dents, or fungus (yuck!) inside the lens.

14. Pottery and Ceramics

AzmanL/istockphoto

Pottery and ceramics from renowned makers like Rookwood, Roseville, or Wedgwood are beloved by collectors for their artistry, craftsmanship, and historical significance (not to mention their nostalgic appeal). Key details to look for include maker’s marks, distinctive glazes, and intricate designs that reflect the era in which they were created.

15. Toys and Games

Vintage Parker Brothers Monopoly Board Game With Wooden Pieces
Onlyboy/eBay

Vintage toys like board games and mini figurines (especially those still in their original packaging) can be incredibly valuable and nostalgic. Keep an eye out for brands like LEGO, Barbie, or Hot Wheels, and check for rarity and condition. Action figures from popular franchises like “Star Wars” and G.I. Joe are also super popular and sought-after.

Meet the Writer

Matt has spent over the last 8 years as both a writer and editor, working in Seattle and Brooklyn, where he is now based. He loves escaping the tirelessly fast pace of the “Mad Apple” that is NYC by taking walks and runs through parks where he’s able to catch up on the latest tea about society from the city’s ever chatty, always hungry, occasionally maniacal, pigeons. They always have a lot to say. When he’s not taking his urban nature strolls, or dutifully combing the deepest rabbit holes of the internet to find the content that’s worth sinking your mind’s teeth into, he’s likely holed up at a dark-lit dive bar with a new book and/or some friends, or just easily he could be on the hunt for the next addition to his steadily growing plant family.