Side-by-side images showing a vintage green one-gallon metal oyster tin and the cover of the novel “Salem’s Lot” by Stephen King.
via Canva

Scoring on a great deal brings with it a wondrous jolt of exhilaration that is one of life’s simplest pleasures. On top of that, every once in a while, those good deals can end up being their own set of rip-roaring, wild deals. These folks certainly encountered their own moments when vintage items sold at surreal initial prices and then blossomed into treasure-like value.

1. When the junk is actually a gem

Electro-Voice Aircraftman Intercom System Model 6000 unit with an attached headset.
JohnsOldFinds / via YouTube.com

“A pair of headphones that I thought were cheap junk for 50p because my headphones had just died on me, and I needed something whilst deciding what to get next. Ended up being vintage 1970s Japanese-made headphones with a weird proprietary connector (the reason I searched them up, wanted to find an adapter because I was too stupid to check the connector before buying). Sold them for £130-ish a week later.” – u/3original5me

2. Don’t overlook skater deals

A vintage wooden skateboard with a simple, elongated deck and blue wheels is placed on a white surface. The skateboard shows signs of wear, giving it a nostalgic and classic look.
Bear Creek Cottage / ebay

“At a rummage sale my husband brought me a tiny wooden skateboard for $2.50 and said, ‘I think this could be worth something.’ I sell clothes, so I rarely look at hard goods. Figured it was worth a gamble for the price. Turns out it was a very rare early skateboard made by a surfboard company. Sold at auction for $200.” – u/sweetsquashy

3. Time to check the kids’ Crayola set

A set of 24 colored pencils neatly arranged in a clear plastic case. The pencils display a variety of colors, including red, blue, pink, yellow, and green, with sharp tips ready for use. Each pencil is labeled, indicating the brand and color.
ThriftingPop/ebay

“Got a set of old, unused colored pencils for $2 at Goodwill. Was planning on giving them to my kids to use. Decided to look them up to see how good a deal I got thinking they were worth maybe $20-30. When I saw the comps I was very surprised and chose to list them. Sold for $200 within an hour of listing.” – u/Lyrehctoo

4. One man’s trash is another man’s treasure

A large Louis Vuitton gift box with a ribbon sits on a tiled floor next to a matching shopping bag. Both are dark with gold and red accents, featuring the Louis Vuitton logo and decorative elements.
5711rr / ebay

“A former billionaire boss used to clean out her closet and just leave stuff in the laundry room for the staff to take/donate/sell. One day, alongside the pile of obvious valuable designer goods was a box of boxes and bags for the dump. All designer names — Louis Vuitton, Manolo Blahnik, Tiffany’s, Louboutin, etc. On a whim on my way to the dumpster, I looked up one box, and was shocked to see they were selling! I got like $75-$90 a box at the time.” – u/ThriftStoreUnicorn

5. Always keep an eye on the kitchen gadgets

A vintage metal box appliance with a lever handle on top and a power cord extending from its base. It is placed on a blue surface and set against a white and silver background.
yassinmahmou-0/ebay

“A can opener for $6, the guy retired and his work let him take it home. Sold for $200 a week later. It was a commercial Edlund Model 266 opener.” – u/Joatoat

6. Dang, Dostoyevsky, it didn’t realize it was like that

A red book cover featuring the title "Crime and Punishment" by Fyodor Dostoevsky, translated by Constance Garnett and illustrated by Benjamin Kopman. The design includes decorative cross-like symbols.
suebell2017/ebay

“Grabbed an old Dostoyevsky for $6 because I thought I could sell it for $20. Turned out to be the 1st American edition. Comps are above $3,500 (but no Solds so the actual value is still TBD).” – u/likelyculprit

7. Now that’s how one turns a profit

The image shows a worn cover of Stephen King's novel "'Salem's Lot." The title is in large white and red text against a black background. The cover features a small illustration of a town, partially torn at the bottom corner.
Giving Books Life Again / ebay

“I bought a beat-up old ex-library book of Stephen King’s ‘Salem’s Lot’ for 50 cents. Was a super rare first edition in which only a few existed (a different name for a main character, a different price, etc). Worth and sold for 5K!” – u/thejohnmc963

8. The Pyrex goldmine is a true sight to behold

A vintage white bowl with a pattern of blue teardrop shapes, each containing a cross, is placed on a light-colored surface. The background shows blurred, decorative objects.
tonbrundidg0 / ebay

“I found a cute, unmarked chip and dip bowl set at a thrift store once. Bought it cause I liked it. It sat in my kitchen for months before I tried to research it. Turns out it was an ultra-rare Pyrex Atomic Eyes chip and dip set. I sold it for about $600.” – u/toodleroo

9. Imagine buying history like that

A round, woven basket with a spiral pattern of alternating light and dark natural fibers. It is displayed upright on a stand in a gallery setting.
purpletreasurechest/ebay

“I bought a Native American basket at Goodwill – COVERED in dust, for $1.99. Thought it was a Zulu basket and worth maybe $30… it was a Navajo basket and worth $1,800.” – u/Chartwellandgodspeed

10. Ornate Oysters anyone?

A vintage green and white can labeled "Original Pac Oysters," with red text and images of oysters. The label mentions "Minimum Volume 1 Gallon" and "Chesapeake Bay's Famous Oyster Beds." The can is placed on a wooden surface.
islander_78 / ebay

“An antique Maryland oyster can. Bought it for 50 cents at a thrift and it sold for nearly $3,000 on an eBay auction.” – u/kciro

Meet the Writer

Matt has spent over the last 8 years as both a writer and editor, working in Seattle and Brooklyn, where he is now based. He loves escaping the tirelessly fast pace of the “Mad Apple” that is NYC by taking walks and runs through parks where he’s able to catch up on the latest tea about society from the city’s ever chatty, always hungry, occasionally maniacal, pigeons. They always have a lot to say. When he’s not taking his urban nature strolls, or dutifully combing the deepest rabbit holes of the internet to find the content that’s worth sinking your mind’s teeth into, he’s likely holed up at a dark-lit dive bar with a new book and/or some friends, or just easily he could be on the hunt for the next addition to his steadily growing plant family.