Hockey is full of hard hits and fast plays, but some players have made headlines for the wrong reasons. Off the ice, their actions have landed them in situations far more serious than a two-minute minor. The following mugshots show that even tough enforcers and star scorers can end up in real trouble. Here is a look at 15 hockey players who got busted, proof that sometimes the penalty box isn’t the worst place you can end up.
1. Chris Nilan- Montreal Canadiens
Nilan’s post-retirement life was marred by arrests for assault and disorderly conduct. His mugshot reflected the darker side of a player once beloved for his toughness, showing how hard it can be to leave the fight behind.
2. Patrick Kane- Chicago Blackhawks
In 2009, Kane’s boy-next-door image took a hit when he was arrested in Buffalo after an altercation with a cab driver over a fare dispute. Though the charges were later reduced, the incident left fans stunned that one of the NHL’s brightest young stars could end up in handcuffs.
3. Chris Pronger- Edmonton Oilers
Known for his bruising style on the ice, Pronger’s aggression spilled over early in his career when he faced assault-related charges. His mugshot became a reminder that even future Hall of Famers can cross the line outside the rink.
4. Bob Probert- Detroit Red Wings
The undisputed king of NHL trouble, Probert was arrested multiple times for drug possession and DUIs. His mugshots became almost as legendary as his fights, cementing his reputation as hockey’s ultimate bad boy.
5. Dany Heatley- Atlanta Thrashers
Heatley’s career was forever marked by tragedy when he was charged after a 2003 car crash that killed teammate Dan Snyder. His mugshot symbolized the devastating consequences of reckless decisions off the ice.
Trending on Wealth Gang
6. Tie Domi- Toronto Maple Leafs
Domi’s fists were famous in the NHL, but his off-ice altercations also landed him in police custody. His mugshot carried the same defiant glare fans saw when he dropped the gloves in the middle of a game.
7. Ron Hextall- Philadelphia Flyers
The fiery goaltender’s temper wasn’t limited to the crease. In the 1980s, Hextall found himself arrested after a violent off-ice incident, proving his reputation for volatility wasn’t just a hockey myth.
8. Sean Avery- New York Rangers
Avery’s antics made headlines on and off the ice, and his arrest for disorderly conduct fit right into his bad-boy persona. His mugshot looked more like a smirk than regret, perfectly in line with his reputation.
Sign up for our newsletter
9. Tyler Totten
At just 18 years old, Totten was arrested in 2024 after a violent attack in Fredericton that led to the death of a 41-year-old man. His mugshot shocked fans due to his age, a reminder that trouble can find players before they even reach the NHL spotlight.
10. Darren McCarty- Detroit Red Wings
McCarty’s battles weren’t just against opponents, financial troubles and substance issues led to arrests that tarnished his tough-guy legacy. His mugshot reflected the struggles of a player once celebrated for grit and glory.
11. Ryan Kesler- Vancouver Canucks / Anaheim Ducks
In October 2025, Kesler was arrested and charged with two misdemeanor counts of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct in Michigan. The case involved allegations of inappropriate contact with a minor, and his mugshot became a shocking reminder that even respected veterans can face serious legal trouble.
12. Stan Jonathan- Boston Bruins
Jonathan’s mugshot came after a tragic hunting accident in 1984 that led to manslaughter charges. Unlike other hockey busts, his case was more about misfortune than malice, but the image still carried weight.
13. Ken Linseman- Philadelphia Flyers
Nicknamed “The Rat” for his pesky playing style, Linseman lived up to the moniker when he was arrested for assault. His mugshot reinforced the idea that his scrappy reputation wasn’t confined to the rink.
14. Ryan O’Reilly- Buffalo Sabres
In 2015, O’Reilly was arrested for impaired driving after crashing his truck into a Tim Hortons. His mugshot became a bizarre footnote in hockey history, a star center colliding with Canada’s most iconic coffee shop.
15. Jim McKenzie- New Jersey Devils
McKenzie’s mugshot followed barroom brawls that mirrored his on-ice enforcer role. Fans weren’t surprised to see his name in police reports, but the image cemented his reputation as a fighter in every arena.
More Stories You’ll Want to Check Out:
If you found this piece intriguing, you will definitely want to explore a few related articles that dive even deeper into the fascinating world of mugshots and their cultural context. Check out 20 Mugshots of College Football Players Who Got Busted for a modern look at how athletes have made headlines off the field, or step back in time with Mugshots from the 1800s and Mugshots from the 1900s to see how crime, punishment, and photography intersected across different eras.
