10 Rare, Expensive Romance Novels That Will Set Your Wallet on Fire

Whether it’s due to limited print runs, iconic authors, or cult followings, certain romance books have become rare collectibles with jaw-dropping price tags. From polarizing classics like “Stormfire” to groundbreaking works like “Indigo,” these novels have earned their spot as some of the priciest in the genre.
If you’re a romance enthusiast or a collector, these ten expensive romance novels might be worth the splurge.
1. ‘Stormfire’ by Christine Monson

Price: $130
As one of the most polarizing and controversial romance novels of the ’80s, Christine Monson’s “Stormfire” has become harder to find over the years due to its mixed reception. While some readers appreciated the depth of the story, others were disturbed by the novel’s darker, violent themes. Because of its scarcity, though, copies of “Stormfire” cost a pretty penny.
2. ‘Indigo’ by Beverly Jenkins

Price: $500
First published in 1996, Beverly Jenkins’ “Indigo” is now out of print, bumping its value up. Signed, first-edition copies are even more rare and worthy of elevated price tags.
3. ‘Outlander’ by Diana Gabaldon

Price: $1,200
Blending historical fiction with riveting romance, “Outlander” might just be the “Harry Potter” of the romance world. Diana Gabaldon’s 1991 novel has spawned several subsequent books to form a beloved series, along with a TV show of the same name with a colossal fanbase. All of that to say, we’re not surprised that a first-edition, signed copy of the original “Outlander” book has an asking price of $1,200 tied to it.
4. ‘The Silver Devil’ by Teresa Denys

Price: $800
Teresa Denys’ “The Silver Devil” was published in 1984. Even though this book’s cover still has a “$3.50” on it, it’s grown a tad more expensive over the years, especially since it’s now out of print.
5. ‘Promise Me Tomorrow’ by Nora Roberts

Price: $200
Nora Roberts is a giant in the romance world, and “Promise Me Tomorrow” has a reputation as one of her most expensive books in the realm. Because this novel is out of print, it’s rare to find a physical copy of it, and even more rare to find one for less than $200.
6. ‘The Flesh and the Devil’ by Teresa Denys

Price: $470
Published in 1980, the novel “The Flesh and the Devil” by Teresa Denys is particularly beloved by fans of historical romance. The book is rare and highly sought after due to its limited print runs and Denys’s untimely passing, which left her bibliography tragically brief.
7. ‘Her Demon Lover’ by Janet Louise Roberts

Price: $130
This book might say “Over 2 million Janet Louise Roberts novels in print” in a bold yellow blurb right on the cover, but that doesn’t apply to this particular novel. “Her Demon Lover” is rare due to its original release during the gothic romance boom of the 1970s and its subsequent limited reprints. You won’t find anywhere near 2 million copies of this novel in circulation now.
8. ‘Shadows on the Bayou’ by Patricia Vaughn

Price: $222
“Shadows on the Bayou” by Patricia Vaughn blends romance, mystery, and cultural richness, creating a vivid portrait of Creole life. The novel is rare due to its limited print run and Vaughn’s status as a trailblazing author of diverse historical romance. It holds a special place for collectors and readers interested in stories with rich historical detail and compelling narratives centering on Black protagonists.
9. ‘Where Passion Leads’ by Lisa Kleypas

Price: $140
While Lisa Kleypas is known for her later works, “Where Passion Leads” is a sought-after collector’s item for fans since it offers an early glimpse into her evolving writing style. Its first novel status makes it especially rare, making original editions both prized and pricey.
10. ‘Hearts Divided’ by Francine Rivers

Price: $151
Francine Rivers has tons of successful novels, but “Hearts Divided” is considered rare because it was published during Rivers’s earlier career as a romance novelist before she transitioned into Christian fiction with the acclaimed “Redeeming Love.” As many of her earlier works went out of print, “Hearts Divided” became one of the most treasured.