9 Rare American Girl Dolls That Every Collector Wants
For over 35 years, American Girl dolls have captured the hearts of kids and adults alike with their expressive eyes and unique styles that reflect the “real world and all its colors, customs, and capabilities.” These dolls have also become far more than just playthings: Some rare models fetch thousands of dollars in the collector’s market. From early editions with subtle manufacturing differences to beloved characters pulled from shelves too soon, here are nine valuable American Girl dolls that reflect the enduring appeal and nostalgia of the brand.
1. Original 1986 Kirsten
As one of the first three American Girl dolls ever released, Kirsten is a must-have for die-hard collectors of the brand. Early versions featuring Kirsten’s red-checked dress and blonde braids are especially prized. Those with complete accessories, including the St. Lucia crown, book, and school supplies, can be worth even more. Discontinued in 2010, well-preserved Kirstens can sell for thousands; in 2021, one sold for over $6,000 at auction. You can currently find one listed for nearly $5,000 on eBay.
2. White Body Samantha
The earliest Samantha dolls with soft white cloth bodies (later changed to tan) are valuable because of their scarcity. Featuring subtle differences, like thicker eyelashes and a softer face mold, these dolls were only on the market for four years before being discontinued. While pristine dolls are listed for around $400, even used ones can sell for upwards of $200.
3. Josefina Montoya
Josefina Montoya dolls were first released in 1997. Her sweet, expressive features and big, dewy brown eyes made her a fan favorite — and since she wasn’t in production for long, she can be pretty hard to find. Complete with her original outfit and documents, she can sell for around $600, and even more if still in her original box.
4. Cécile Rey
Cécile Rey, known as fellow American Girl doll Marie-Grace’s best friend, was only available for three years before being discontinued in 2014. As part of a less-popular historical duo, fewer Cécile Reys were made. But her bouncy curls and elaborate Victorian outfits made her a standout. Today, fans and collectors are willing to pay upwards of $400 for a new-in-box Cécile; one’s listed for $480 on eBay.
5. Caroline Abbott
Caroline, known as the War of 1812 doll, had a short production run after being released in 2012. As part of the BeForever collection, her pink nautical-themed collection and intricate braided hairstyle made her a standout (though you can also keep her blonde locks roaming free). Since she wasn’t on shelves for long, she’s now a rare find. Complete sets in “good” or “fair” condition are listed for around $100, while those in original packaging can go for even more (over $500).
6. Limited-Edition Ruthie
Ruthie was only sold for one year before being cut in 2008. Her adorable accessories (where can we buy that super cute purse and watch?!) and Depression-era outfits made her charming but underrated. But that’s changed today, with collectors willing to pay top dollar for new, in-box Ruthies. Even used ones can command prices exceeding $250 thanks to her rarity. One recently sold for over $400 on eBay.
7. Limited Edition #21
This doll was part of a small batch of limited-edition “Girl of Today” releases in 2009. Her unique combination of blonde hair, freckles, and brown eyes made her quite distinctive. Since she wasn’t restocked, she’s now considered pretty rare, with collectors willing to pay around $100 for her, especially in original packaging or with all accessories included.
8. Marisol Luna
Marisol, known as the first Hispanic “Girl of the Year,” was only available for a year before she was retired in 2005. Though she wasn’t around for long, her ballet-themed collection and long dark curls made her a fan-favorite as well as a collector’s gem. Mint-condition Marisol dolls with all accessories included are listed for over $500 on eBay.
9. German Samantha
When American Girl first expanded internationally, a small batch of Samantha dolls were sold in West Germany with unique tags and packaging. These ultra-rare exports are nearly identical to the U.S. version but have a tiny “Made for Germany” label. Because so few were produced, you’ll find the doll listed at upwards of $700.
Take a look at our stories about valuable Barbie dolls, porcelain dolls, and vintage Cabbage Patch dolls to see how they stack up against these American Girl dolls.