10 Beat-Up Collectibles That Still Sell for Big Money
When it comes to collectibles, you might think that only flawless items are worth big bucks. But surprisingly, even damaged or incomplete items can fetch impressive sums if they’re rare or tied to a beloved brand. From ripped designer jeans to board games missing half their pieces, collectors are often willing to overlook flaws for the chance to own something unique or historic.
Here are 10 items that can still sell for surprising amounts, even in less-than-perfect condition.
1. Ripped Name-Brand Jeans
Vintage Levi’s or designer jeans with holes or fraying can still sell for hundreds (or even thousands of dollars). Though they may look faded and worn-in, some collectors will actually pay a premium for that rugged, authentic style.
2. Broken Luxury Watches
Even non-functioning Rolexes can sell for thousands thanks to their prestige and reputation. So if you have a broken luxury watch gathering dust in a drawer, don’t write it off just yet — many can be easily restored and sold for surprising amounts.
3. Board Games With Missing Pieces
Classic vintage board games like Monopoly, Yahtzee, and Dungeons & Dragons sets from the 1970s or earlier can still sell for hundreds, even if they’re incomplete or missing original packaging and manuals. Remember: Nostalgia drives demand.
4. Damaged Concert Posters
Vintage concert posters stemming from iconic bands like The Beatles, Rolling Stones, or Nirvana — even those with tears or water damage — can fetch hundreds (or even thousands) thanks to their nostalgic appeal, cult following, and rarity.
5. Cracked Vintage Pottery
Pieces from acclaimed brands like McCoy or Roseville, even with chips or cracks, can sell for surprising amounts thanks to collectors who value the artistry, craftsmanship, and the history behind them.
6. Worn Sneakers
Limited-edition vintage sneakers (think early Air Jordans or kicks signed by elite athletes like Michael Jordan or Kobe Byrant) can sell for high thousands (or millions) — even if they’re scuffed or worn. Just consider these Air Jordan 1s from 1985 that sold for a record-smashing $560,000 at an auction in 2020.
7. Incomplete Toy Sets
Action figures or playsets from the 1970s and beyond — especially those that feature toys from beloved franchises like “Star Wars” or “He-Man” — can still sell for surprising amounts, even if they’re missing accessories or original packaging.
8. Torn Vintage Band T-Shirts
Stained or ripped concert tees from beloved musicians, especially rock and heavy metal bands like AC/DC, The Cure, or Led Zeppelin, can sell for hundreds due to their cultural significance and influence in pop culture and beyond.
9. Damaged Comic Books
Vintage comic book issues with tears or missing pages can still sell for hundreds or thousands if they’re part of a limited-edition print or feature the debut of a character.
10. Broken Vintage Electronics
Old but revered gaming consoles like the Atari 2600, first-edition Nintendos, or Game Boys, can sell for hundreds, even if they have missing keys or need to be refurbished. Collectors will still seek to repair them or use them for display purposes.