It’s fascinating, and it’s a visceral display of the effects of time when one considers various collectibles. From the Beanie Babies to the porcelain figures and collectible plates, these nostalgic “investments” have nearly lost all their value. Seriously, what once filled display cases and also hope chests is now cluttering literal eBay listings for just a few dollars apiece. And that’s ridiculous. Here’s a look at some of the most popular collectibles that then turned out to be financially worthless, even if they manage to still hold sentimental value.
1. Junk Wax Baseball Cards
Those binders that decorated the rooms in the late 1980s and then also the early 1990s had baseball cards that would end up looking like literal future retirement funds. It’s crazy how much the value of baseball cards can appreciate over time.
2. Avon Collectible Perfume Bottles
Avon made its bathroom shelves much like miniature museums. In that many common bottles dating back to the 1970s were discovered, and the ’80s now have the modest resale value factored in as well. Rare designs too, are the exceptoin here.
3. Commemorative State Quarters
If you (or a well-meaning relative) meticulously collected every single state quarter, hoping they’d be worth a fortune one day, bad news. Unless you have an error coin or a rare misprint, those quarters are still worth… well, 25 cents. But hey, at least they’re still money!
4. Beanie Babies
While the 1990s craze saw collectors scrambling to snag these stuffed toys as investments, expecting them to pay for college or even early retirement, the reality hasn’t lived up to the hype. Sure, some Beanie Babies are worth money, but typically only if they’re rare, in mint condition, or have errors. Today, most Beanie Babies are worth little more than a nostalgic trip down memory lane; many sell for as little as $1 on eBay.
5. Longaberger Baskets
Once the ultimate status symbol of home decor catalogs and “investment” parties, Longaberger baskets were handcrafted, expensive, and supposedly destined to increase in value. Unfortunately, the market has tanked, and today you can grab them at thrift stores for a few bucks — or from eBay and Etsy sellers desperate to offload their collections.
Trending on Wealth Gang
6. Norman Rockwell Plates
Norman Rockwell collector plates were a big hit back in the day and featured classic, heartwarming artwork. Unfortunately, thanks to mass production, they’re not worth a whole lot anymore. Plenty of plates sell for just a few dollars apiece on eBay.
7. Hess Trucks
Hess trucks were first sold as holiday toys in the ’60s and have become a favorite among collectors. These battery-powered trucks, usually decked out with cool lights and holiday designs, were once the perfect gift for kids. Nowadays, collectors hunt down older models, especially the limited edition ones, which can go for decent prices. But, spoiler alert: Some of the newer ones from the early 2000s aren’t worth much at all.
8. Precious Moments Figurines
Don’t look at us with those pouty faces, Precious Moments — it’s not our fault you’re not top-dollar these days. With their signature teardrop-eyed characters, Precious Moments figurines are one of the most well-known collectible figurines. But being well-known does not automatically make them valuable. While they were once highly collectible, their market value has declined due to mass production and changing trends. Today, you can score these figures for less than $10 apiece on eBay (at the low end).
Sign up for our newsletter
9. Vintage McDonald’s Glasses
Vintage McDonald’s glasses, featuring iconic characters like Grimace and the Hamburglar or themes like Star Wars and Coca-Cola, are nostalgic reminders of the glory days of fast food (the 1970s and ’80s, duh). While they once came with every Happy Meal or for a small upcharge, these glasses now appeal to collectors for their retro charm. As appealing as they are, though, they’re still not worth a whole lot — some individual glasses are being sold for a penny apiece on eBay!
10. Dreamsicles Figurines
Not to be confused with the orange popsicles filled with vanilla ice cream, Dreamsicle figurines were known for their cherubic faces and whimsical charm. Though they were a popular collectible in the 1990s, you can find them for $1 each on eBay nowadays.
11. Disney VHS Tapes
At some point, a rumor spread that Disney’s “Black Diamond” VHS tapes were worth thousands of dollars. Spoiler alert: They’re not. While a few rare misprints might sell for slightly more, and while plenty of off-their-rocker eBay sellers list them for tens of thousands, most of these tapes are practically worthless. You’ll find them at thrift stores for a dollar or less, right next to the dusty VCRs no one uses anymore.
12. Cherished Teddies Figurines
I would have been sent to my room with no dinner if I had told my mother in the ’90s that her beloved Cherished Teddies figurines would be on eBay for less than $12 apiece in 2025. But I would’ve been right.
13. Cabbage Patch Kids
Remember the chaos of the ’80s when parents were literally fighting in stores to get their hands on these chubby-cheeked dolls? While some ultra-rare editions can fetch eye-catching prices, the majority of Cabbage Patch Kids are worth next to nothing. You can find plenty of them listed for under $10 on eBay — some still in their boxes!
14. Bradford Exchange Plates
From sports stars to wildlife, Bradford Exchange plates became popular in the ’80s and ’90s. While they aren’t as sought after today (we found one for as little as $1 on eBay), they still hold sentimental value for collectors who appreciate the memories tied to them — nostalgia, after all, doesn’t have a price tag.
15. Hummel Figurines
Once the crown jewels of Grandma’s curio cabinet, Hummel figurines were supposed to be valuable heirlooms. Unfortunately, they’re now mostly collecting dust in estate sales and thrift stores, with many selling for $5 to $20. Like many things, though, some rare figures are worth something.
