13 Beanie Babies Worth an Obscene Amount of Money
Remember when Beanie Babies came out and we were all obsessed with collecting them all? Some folks wouldn’t take the plastic off the ear tags, while others would keep the toys in a special collector case. Over time, the craze faded, and people stuffed their bean-filled characters in a trash bag. Some even made the critical mistake of donating or selling them for dirt-cheap prices at a garage sale.
These days, nostalgic items like VHS tapes and vinyl records can fetch a fortune — and so do Beanie Babies. People list them for big bucks and hope that some deep-pocketed collector will help them get rich quick. Here are some of the Beanie Babies people hawk for the highest prices.
1. Chef Robuchon the Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $35,000 on eBay
Created as a tribute to the legendary French chef Joël Robuchon, who held the most Michelin stars in the world, Chef Robuchon the Bear is no ordinary collectible. Released in extremely limited quantities and only available at select Robuchon restaurants, it was the modern-day equivalent of a limited-edition Stanley Tumbler being released. With its rarity and connection to such a celebrated figure, this Beanie Baby has fetched prices in the thousands.
2. #1 Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $9,000 on eBay
The #1 Bear is a true Beanie Baby legend and one of the rarest out there. It wasn’t mass-produced like most others — this bear was made as a special tribute to Ty Warner, the mastermind behind Beanie Babies. Only a handful were ever created, and instead of hitting store shelves, they were either given as personal gifts or auctioned off for charity, making it a real challenge to find. With its bold red fabric and the shiny gold “#1” stitched on its chest, this bear stands out as a top-tier collector’s item that has sold for tens of thousands of dollars.
3. Millennium Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $500,000 on eBay
The turn into the new millennium was a huge deal rolling into 2000, marked by everything from wild Y2K fears to massive global celebrations. And, of course, even Beanie Babies got in on the excitement with the release of the Millennium Bear. Introduced in late 1999, this plush bear was created to commemorate the historic event.
What makes the Millennium Bear even more special is its unique variations, like misspellings on some tags (where “Millennium” was accidentally printed as “Millenium”). These little errors have turned some bears into collector’s gold, with rare versions fetching hundreds of thousands of dollars.
4. Patti the Platypus
Highest Current Listing Price: $20,000 on eBay
The late ’90s saw Beanie Babies fever reach its peak, and one of the original breakout stars was Patti the Platypus. Released in 1993, Patti is one of the earliest Beanie Babies. As one of Ty’s original designs, Patti holds a special place in Beanie Baby history and helped launch the craze that followed.
Collectors adore Patti not just for her early release, but also because of the different variations that make her even more unique. Some versions have different shades of color or rare tag errors, which can seriously increase her value. Depending on the condition and rarity, Patti the Platypus can sell for hundreds, or tens of thousands of dollars.
5. Coral Casino Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $4,400 on eBay
Created specifically for the guests of the Coral Casino Beach and Cabana Club in Santa Barbara, California, this Beanie bear features a soft coral-colored fur and chic embroidered details that scream luxury. Since it was never available in stores, it has become a highly sought-after collectible, with prices soaring on the resale market well into the thousands.
6. Billionaire Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $28,000 on eBay
Released as part of Ty’s 1999 lineup, the Billionaire Bear was sold in a variety of colors, with an embroidered dollar sign on its plushy chest. What really boosts its desirability is the fact that it was released during a time of significant hype around Beanie Babies (it was, after all, inspired by the fact that Ty reached the billion Beanies sold milestone) and its limited availability. Depending on its condition and whether it retains its original tags, the Billionaire Bear can fetch impressive prices, often reaching into the thousands.
7. Royal Blue Peanut the Elephant
Highest Current Listing Price: $16,000 on eBay
Originally released in 1995, Peanut was initially available in a standard light blue color, but the royal blue variant quickly became the star of the show. The royal blue version was only produced for a short time, leading to its high demand and impressive resale value. Some collectors are willing to pay thousands for a well-preserved Peanut with its original tags.
8. Princess the Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $1,000,000 on eBay
When it comes to Beanie Babies, Princess the Bear might just be the most legendary of them all. Introduced in 1997, this special bear was created to honor the late Princess Diana, who was a cultural phenomenon at the time, and its striking purple color symbolizes the purple hue associated with her charity work.
What makes this bear truly unique is its limited production; only a small number were made, which has significantly boosted its value over the years. Some versions have even sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars, especially those with rare tags or errors.
9. Pinchers the Lobster
Highest Current Listing Price: $20,000 on eBay
Pinchers the Lobster is a quirky and fun addition to the Beanie Baby lineup, originally released in 1995. Although Pinchers might not be as rare as some of the more sought-after bears, certain versions with tag errors or unique features can fetch a nice price on the collector’s market.
10. Chocolate the Moose
Highest Current Listing Price: $50,000 on eBay
Chocolate the Moose was released in 1993 with the original babes, and while it may not be the rarest Beanie Baby out there, certain editions — especially those with unique tag variations — can still rake in impressive prices on the resale market. Many collectors cherish this moose for its nostalgic appeal as one of the O.G. Beanies.
11. Peace the Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $150,000 on eBay
Peace the Bear debuted in 1997 amid a growing cultural interest in peace and unity — and a resurgence of tie dye and peace symbols. Certain versions of Peace the Bear, especially those with unique tag variations or limited releases, can be quite valuable among collectors. Peace is also said to be one of the first Beanie Babies to sport an embroidered emblem on its chest.
12. Valentino Bear
Highest Current Listing Price: $250,000 on eBay
Released in 1994 in honor of Valentine’s Day, this adorable bear is dressed to impress with its rich red fur and a cute little bowtie. Valentino is one of the most memorable holiday-themed Beanie Babies, and these days, it’s one of the most sought-after by collectors, too.
13. Mystic the Unicorn
Highest Current Listing Price: $500,000 on eBay
Mystic the Unicorn was released in 1994 and its popularity and nostalgic appeal have made it a favorite among collectors. Not to mention the iridescent horn and the fact that unicorns are just plain cute and fun. Certain editions, especially those with tag variations or special features, can get pretty expensive.